I recently encountered a Haskell function which apparently requires "higher-rank" type constraints. I worked around the issue with some type trickery. I'd like to share the problem and the workaround, and especially get feedback on whether there's a better solution.
I did say type trickery:
{-# LANGUAGE
GADTs
, FlexibleContexts
, RankNTypes
, ScopedTypeVariables #-}
Suppose we're implementing an in-place sorting algorithm. We'll use the ST
monad, so that we can expose a pure interface. Assuming that we only want to sort primitive types, we will use the unboxed STUArray
type, which should improve space and time usage. Actually, it's totally unwarranted premature optimization for the sake of the problem. :)
import Control.Monad.ST
import Data.Array.ST
The monadic part of this code is simple enough. I've left out the part where we actually, you know, sort the list. Consult your bedside copy of CLRS.
sortM
:: forall a s.
(Ord a, MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s))
=> [a]
-> ST s [a]
sortM xs = do
arr <- newListArray (1, length xs) xs
:: ST s (STUArray s Int a)
-- do some in-place sorting here
getElems arr
Note that sortM
has a constraint MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s)
. All we're really saying is that a
is a type primitive enough that STUArray
can unbox it. The rest of the constraint just connects the concrete world of STUArray
with the generic MArray
interface.
Note also that we give an explicit type on our call to newListArray
. Otherwise, there's nothing to constrain what sort of array we get, and GHC will complain of ambiguity. Furthermore, we need to unify this a
and s
with the a
and s
from the signature on sortM
. We do that using the ScopedTypeVariables
extension and the explicit forall
. (If you turn on UnicodeSyntax
you can write it as ∀
; how cool is that?)
Good enough so far. Now, the point of using ST
was to expose a pure interface, right?
sortP_1 :: (Ord a) => [a] -> [a]
sortP_1 xs = runST (sortM xs)
Suddenly GHC is very unhappy:
Could not deduce (MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s)) from the context ()
arising from a use of `sortM' at code.hs:21:20-27
Possible fix:
add (MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s)) to the context of
the polymorphic type `forall s. ST s a'
or add an instance declaration for (MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s))
In the first argument of `runST', namely `(sortM xs)'
In the expression: runST (sortM xs)
In the definition of `sortP_1': sortP_1 xs = runST (sortM xs)
Okay, fair enough. We've given no reason for GHC to believe that a
is an STUArray
-compatible type. Let's copy over the constraint from sortM
:
sortP_2
:: (Ord a, MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s))
=> [a] -> [a]
sortP_2 xs = runST (sortM xs)
Still no good:
Could not deduce (MArray (STUArray s1) a (ST s1))
from the context ()
arising from a use of `sortM' at code.hs:27:20-27
Possible fix:
add (MArray (STUArray s1) a (ST s1)) to the context of
the polymorphic type `forall s. ST s a'
or add an instance declaration for (MArray (STUArray s1) a (ST s1))
In the first argument of `runST', namely `(sortM xs)'
In the expression: runST (sortM xs)
In the definition of `sortP_2': sortP_2 xs = runST (sortM xs)
Note that GHC gives an error about the variable s1
, not s
. This is a valuable hint. Our caller (notionally) chooses one s
when she provides evidence to satisfy the constraint MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s)
. Then runST
(notionally) gets to choose a different s
because of its higher-rank type.
What to do? It's useless for our caller to pick some particular s
and provide evidence. We need that evidence for all s
:
sortP_3
:: (Ord a, forall s. MArray (STUArray s) a (ST s))
=> [a] -> [a]
sortP_3 xs = runST (sortM xs)
Unfortunately, GHC does not support this "higher-rank constraint":
code.hs:32:13: malformed class assertion
Well... the ->
of functions and the =>
of constraints are not as different as they may appear. A Haskell compiler can implement type classes by translating constraints to explicit "dictionary" arguments. Let's do the same thing ourselves:
data Evidence s e where
Evidence
:: (MArray (STUArray s) e (ST s))
=> Evidence s e
We don't quite need to reproduce the MArray
methods in our "dictionary". (That's good, because some of them are hidden. A strange class indeed.) It's enough to write a GADT constructor with this constrained type. The constructor will implicitly capture the constraint evidence (such as a dictionary) from its call-site.
Now we need to express the universal quantification on s
:
data ElemType e = ElemType (forall s. Evidence s e)
A (non-⊥) value of type ElemType e
is evidence that e
is a suitable element type for STUArray
. That's all we wanted the caller to say in the first place!
Now we can pass the appropriate evidence:
sortP_4
:: forall a.
(Ord a)
=> ElemType a
-> [a] -> [a]
sortP_4 (ElemType Evidence) xs = runST (sortM xs)
Not quite:
Couldn't match expected type `forall s. Evidence s a'
against inferred type `Evidence s e'
In the pattern: Evidence
In the pattern: ElemType Evidence
In the definition of `sortP_4':
sortP_4 (ElemType Evidence) xs = runST (sortM xs)
GHC still wants some coaxing to match up this s
with the other s
. We push the pattern-matching of Evidence
inside runST
:
sortP_5
:: forall a.
(Ord a)
=> ElemType a
-> [a] -> [a]
sortP_5 (ElemType e) xs = runST (f e) where
f :: Evidence s a -> ST s [a]
f Evidence = sortM xs
And...
[1 of 1] Compiling Main ( code.hs, interpreted )
Ok, modules loaded: Main.
*Main>
A glorious sight! Then, a moment of concern: is sortP_5
actually usable? Does ElemType
have non-⊥ values? Let's check:
*Main> sortP_5 (ElemType Evidence) ([3,4] :: [Int])
[3,4]
Nice. It's sorted and everything. :) As expected, this works only for unboxable types:
*Main> sortP_5 (ElemType Evidence) ["foo","bar"]
<interactive>:1:18:
Could not deduce (MArray (STUArray s) [Char] (ST s))
from the context ()
arising from a use of `Evidence' at <interactive>:1:18-25
As usual, this interesting exercise came from a question on the #haskell
IRC channel. That's why it's one of my favorite places, even if they do specialize in making GHC cry.
Thanks for sharing. I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopeful that you will write many more posts like this one.
ReplyDeleteBIG NEWS
Hello I'm happy to see your post keep it up click here to downlod android apps
ReplyDeleteAPKMirror
Nice blog
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing this information
Get the details of the blog performance
Here:https://www.leadmirror.com/
very honest and well written post. I really appreciate your hard work thanks for sharing such a nice post.
ReplyDeletePlease visit my Collection of Sai Baba Images, krishna Images , Hanuman Images and many hindu god images
Status4Everyone
ReplyDeletegym quotes
gaana.site
very useful information Many thanks for sharing with Me
ReplyDeleteBackground Images For Photoshop Editing Hd Online
Photoscissors Serial Key
Tamilrockers New Link
tamilrockers 2018
Tamilrockers Latest Domain
Png Text Images
Thank You So much for sharing informtion on your website.Your website is very informative to people.
ReplyDeleteQMobile Noir A1 Price and Specifications Full Details
ReplyDeletees app locker
mobogenie for pc
faceapp pro apk
pokesniper apk
App cloner premium
clash of clans mod apk
Quite Impressive article loved it. Keep up the good work
ReplyDeleteVisit here for downloading HD movies
Download Latest Movies
Download free Movies
best Bollywood Movies
best Hollywood movies
Download Dubbed movies
This is the best blogspot blog i came accross. Thanks if you want visit my site for shayari Teachers Day Shayari and Quotes
ReplyDeleteNice blog.
ReplyDeleteAlbert Einstein 10 intersting fats that no One knows
10 Invention made by Indians That changed the world
Best India Newspaper
ReplyDeleteNice article. Keep sharing such post. 9xmovies Download latest movies. Thanks once again.
ReplyDeleteThank You So much for sharing informtion on your website.Your website is very informative to people.
ReplyDeletePhoto Animator App Android
nw-31297-2
ReplyDeletePS4 External Hard Drive – Top Product Of 2019
ce-34788-0
You have a good looking web site
Your site is exactly what I have looking for!! Keep up with the good work.
Thank you for explaining this function correctly and deeply you make my concept clear.
ReplyDeletemovierulz
IndoXXI Pro APK – Nonton Film Subtitle indonesia Gratis, Mudah untuk di gunakan, indoxx1 pro sangat berkualitas, sangat keren, nonton jadi mudah 🙂 Indoxxi Apk Lite Pro Download adalah aplikasi untuk mencari informasi film-film terbaru yang ada di indoxxi indoxx1 lk21 layarkaca21.
ReplyDeleteIndoxxi
IndoXXI
Cara Download Film di INDOXXI
I have to share something and this is related to top beaches and amazing and awesome places to visit in India and outside india if you need tourist visa you can approach us we'll help you to get visa of countries. So why you are stressed, release your stress and find topbeach and places near to you to visit and enjoy your life
ReplyDeletetop beaches in Bali and find out things to do in bali
Thank you for writing can I say something for those people who are looking for one of the best website to find details about latest gadget launch, there price, fac3book, dslr full form, USSd code of airtel, idea and protected text like websites so why you are finding, its here read out
realme powerbank 10000 mah power bank by realme
Looking for the mnc companies in noidathen we are providing you the bestlist of manufacturing companies in noida for you. We also provide you the bestmarketing automation services. sales automation software.
ReplyDeleteThanks Admin For That Great article. you may also like Our website Pinoyteleseryetambayan is offering free videos in Best result dramas of All channels of Philippine Like GMA7 Network & ABS-CBN of all Pinoy Teleserye
ReplyDeleteThis article is very good but you should also know about TAMILROCKERS
ReplyDeleteMADRASROCKERS
REASONS TO GET STARTED IN BLOGGING
MOVIERULZ
MOVIERULZ
Latest Whatsapp Status
Weird things about MUMBAI
BEST PROFITABLE ADVICE
WHO CONTROL THE INTERNET
HOW TO INCREASE STAMINA
Such a nice article love it post more
ReplyDeleteA fascinating discussion is worth comment. I believe that you need to publish more about this topic, it may not be a taboo matter but generally people do not discuss such issues. To the next! Kind regards!!
ReplyDeleteChances are high to win in KBC India, Check these links...
https://kbcgameshow.biz
https://kbcgameshow.biz/kbc-winner-game-is-worth-lacs/
https://kbcgameshow.biz/kbc-lottery-winner-2019/
https://kbcgameshow.biz/kbc-head-office-number-official-helpline-to-contact/
https://kbcgameshow.biz/airtel-lottery-winners-lottery-of-the-year-2019/
https://kbcgameshow.biz/idea-lottery-winners-idea-kbc-winners-2019/
https://kbcgameshow.biz/jio-lottery-winner-tricks/
https://kbcgameshow.biz/vodafone-lottery-winner-2019-vodafone-golden-lottery/
Thanks Again !
Very Nice and good article thanks for share this article 먹튀 검증사이트
ReplyDeleteVery informative and great post. Thank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteCompare prices in Sri Lanka
very nice article Schlafprobleme
ReplyDeletearray for private toto site 토토사이트.You have?
ReplyDeleteThank you for your good information
ReplyDeleteI will always support you to do your best in everything.
I hope to have a good exchange in the future
먹튀검증사이트
This idea blew my mind.검증사이트
ReplyDeleteThere is also a skid plate which ensures that bottom of the kayak stays solid and intact even on the rocky surface – it makes it durable. It is a perfect tandem kayak for beginners and intermediates.
ReplyDeleteTop 10 Best Tandem Kayaks
seo company surat
ReplyDeletei am read your article thank you so much for sgare this amazing article sir
ReplyDeleteCheck my best site: 토토사이트
If you are interested in then we can provide you thecompany directory and data provider
ReplyDeleteWe also provide sales automation and marketing automation.
I wonder what would have happened if I made this 온라인바카라
ReplyDeleteNice info! 바카라사이트
ReplyDeletevery nice article Augentropfen trockene Augen
ReplyDeletethank you very much for share this amazing article i like your website check my website 파워볼사이트
ReplyDeletei like your website and post your writing is very good please keep it up 토토사이트
ReplyDeletecool blog i hope i can learn more about this! check my website https//:hpx7.com 토토 사이트
ReplyDeleteUsually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it.
ReplyDeletetry to visit our site once: http://hky7.com 토토 사이트
Nice article thanks for sharing and if u have some time feel free to visit our site https://hpx7.com
ReplyDelete바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteHey want some interesting site?
Then check this out
https://hpx7.com 바카라사이트
Learn more and enjoy!
You completed a number of fine points there. I did a search on the topic and found nearly all people will go along with with your blog. 먹튀검증
ReplyDeleteHello, Neat post. There is a problem together with your website in web explorer, could test this¡K IE still is the marketplace leader and a large section of other folks will leave out your fantastic writing due to this problem.무료웹툰
ReplyDeleteWhether you are a PC or a console gamer, you may spend hundreds of hours performing tasks, taking quests, and fighting enemies. As such, relaxation is the first criterion that matters when picking the ideal gambling earbuds.
ReplyDeletepc gaming earbuds
Basically, if you have a house and need to sell it fast “now”… we’d like to make you a FAIR cash offer and close on it when you’re ready.
ReplyDeleteWe Buy Houses Greenfield WI
As you know, each person is very busy in this modern era. So, some people search for the best way to get entertainment in their free moments
ReplyDeleteGoGo anime
As you know, hundreds of people want the best way to enjoy or spent their free moments for fun. People have different wishes for this purpose. Also, they are using different things for enjoyment
ReplyDeleteKiss anime
Very Information i like your article 우리카지노
ReplyDeleteVery NIce Article thanks for share this amazing article They are only 30 minutes from Encase in Canada of the hole.I loved the Florist and Accessories shop in Padilla led Monte, in the Community of Madrid. 우리카지노
ReplyDeletePermainan slot yang paling banyak diminati oleh semua orang, tentunya disitus kami dengan permainan slot terlengkap, pastinya akan membuat kalian betah permainan slot apa yang kalian dulu mainkan tentunya akan ada disini. silahkan kunjungi situs kami
ReplyDeleteAgen Slot Vivo Indonesia
agen resmi slot vivo Indonesia
agen resmi slot vivo
cara daftar slot vivo
daftar akun vivo
cara daftar vivo slot
vivo slot
daftar vivo tembak ikan
Login Vivo Slot
Deposit Pulsa Vivo Slot
Withdraw vivo slot
Livechat Vivo Slot Indonesia
aplikasi vivo
download vivo apk
aplikasi slot vivo
download aplikasi vivo
download aplikasi slot vivo
aplikasi vivo android
aplikasi vivo ios
apk slot vivo<br
satta king
ReplyDeleteBruc Bond endeavor to lead the financial sector with sustainability, customizable product offering, and open communication. At Bruc Bond we aim to make 21st century banking straightforward, simple, and transparent.
ReplyDeleteBruc Bond
Once Notarially Certified, certain documents may require further certification such as the affixing of an Apostille certificate or on some occasions Consular legislation is required
ReplyDeleteNotary Southall
전 세계 사람들은 농구를보고 놀면서 수많은 시간을 보내 게됩니다. 사실, 대부분의 플레이어는 여전히 게임에 대해 배울 수있는 것들이 더 재미있어집니다. 농구 통찰력을 얻으려면 독서를 계속하십시오.
ReplyDelete많은 사람들이 방어가 승리의 열쇠라는 것을 깨닫지 못하고 게임의 공격적인 부분에만주의를 기울입니다. 방어는 농구 경기에서이기는 것입니다. 공격은 칭찬과 관심을 모두 얻지 만, 좋은 방어력이 없으면 모든 농구 팀이 패배하게됩니다.
머리가 올라가고 눈이 앞으로 오는 동안 물이 뚝뚝 떨어지십시오. 드리블 중 어떤 이유로 든 볼을보고 있다면 연습을 충분히하지 않은 것입니다. 어디를 가든 볼이 함께 갈 수 있습니다. 당신의 사서함에 걸어? 공을 드리블하십시오. 공에주의를 기울이면 게임의 나머지 부분에주의를 기울이지 않습니다.
점프 기술을 개발할 때는 웨이트 트레이닝 사용을 제한하십시오. 너무 큰 부피의 근육으로 무게를 줄이면 점프 샷에 부정적인 영향을 줄 수 있습니다. 일부 사격 경비원들은 무기를 너무 많이 사용하여 필드 목표의 백분율을 낮추기 시작했습니다.
상대를 속이는 데 관심이 있으십니까? 백 패스를 시도하십시오. 공을 사용하려면 가장 지배적 인 손에 공을 넣으십시오. 그런 다음 공을 등 뒤로 제자리에 당기십시오. 공을 전달할 방향으로 손목으로 빠르게 튕 깁니다. 이것은 상대 팀을 혼동시키는 매우 유용한 트릭입니다.
농구는 개인적인 신체 활동이나 팬 광경으로 즐거움의 원천입니다. 게임을 향상 시키거나 이해력을 높이려면 항상 스포츠에 대해 최대한 많은 지식을 얻는 것이 좋습니다. 이 기사에서는 필요한 팁을 제공했습니다파워볼사이트.
Alleen op die manier kunt u er zeker van zijn dat alles zonder zorgen zal verlopen. Het is dan ook belangrijk om te weten dat wij een specifieke werkwijze hanteren om dit altijd op de juiste wijze te verzorgen.
ReplyDeleteVerhuisbedrijf XXL
Are you all looking for the latest teer result 2020.
ReplyDeleteAls je een partytent huurt is het belangrijk om ook aan de aankleding en inrichting te denken. Het is wel zo praktisch om dat ook bij Colors Events te regelen. Wij kunnen behalve jouw partytent ook zorgen voor meubilair zoals statafels, al dan niet voorzien van rokken, stoelen of gewone tafels. Ook feestverlichting mag niet ontbreken als je een feest in de avonduren organiseert
ReplyDeleteBekijk de website
Webactueel schakel je in als je een maatwerk WordPress website laten maken wilt. Door een maatwerk website te ontwikkelen is het mogelijk om meer leads te genereren. Daarbij hebben we altijd oren voor de wensen en eisen die jij als ondernemer hebt als het om jouw website gaat. Bovendien gaat het om meer dan alleen een website. Ook het toepassen van de juist online marketingstrategie helpt hier in grote mate bij. Wij kunnen dit allemaal voor je verzorgen.
ReplyDeleteWebactueel
Webactueel schakel je in als je een maatwerk WordPress website laten maken wilt. Door een maatwerk website te ontwikkelen is het mogelijk om meer leads te genereren. Daarbij hebben we altijd oren voor de wensen en eisen die jij als ondernemer hebt als het om jouw website gaat. Bovendien gaat het om meer dan alleen een website. Ook het toepassen van de juist online marketingstrategie helpt hier in grote mate bij. Wij kunnen dit allemaal voor je verzorgen.
ReplyDeleteBekijk website
The lots of women ask, can we take protein shakes breastfeeding. They want to use protein powder shakes in breastfeeding
ReplyDeleteprotein shakes breastfeeding
The weight loss bracelet and magnetic devices are freely available in the market. People use it for weight reduction.
ReplyDeletebest hair vitamins for black hair growth
It ’s a mysterious and wonderful thing. I ’m always watching you.해외스포츠중계
ReplyDeletei think you are very great person because your website is very nice 메이저사이트
ReplyDeleteTop Chauffeur service in Melbourne
ReplyDeleteWhether you need a last minute chauffeur car or a planned vehicle for your outing, book with us and get served on time. With well-mannered chauffeurs and finest vehicles, we arrange to pick and drop our customers with great punctuality. A hassle-free traveling experience waits at Silver Executive Cab for every customer
먹튀확인
ReplyDelete안녕하세요 안전한 카지노와 각종 게임들이 여러분을 기다리고 있습니다.
Digikeytech is a free online information encyclopedia, News Great knowledge base of facts, Life Pro, information Hub.
ReplyDeletedigikeytech
Very very knowledgable.
ReplyDeletepak24tv.com
city 41 live
city 42 live
hum tv live
apna tv live
Thanks for sharing this valuable information. Also know about the Top 10 Hollywood Movies.
ReplyDeleteGreat aritcle I really enjoyed it. Also read my blog www.techtually.com
ReplyDeletehelo friends,
ReplyDeletevisit my website snd enjoy love poetry and sad poetry.
https://www.urdugreatpoetry.com/2020/04/Sad-Poetry-for-love.html?m=1
I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people 파워볼 메이저 사이트
ReplyDeleteSuch an interesting post. I will use your advices for my essay writing service uk 파워볼사이트
ReplyDeleteVery nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share, I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks!.
ReplyDeletehttps://youtubemp3converts.com/
Asta Achievers is the top and leading training organization in Gurgaon that help thousands of students with ielts training and service.ielts coaching in gurgaon
ReplyDeleteThe essence of interior design will always be about people and how they live. It is about the realities of what makes for an attractive, civilized, meaningful environment, not about fashion or what's in or what's out. This is not an easy job.interior designer in gurgaon
shayari
Being a reliable and top-rated digital marketing agency in India, our certified marketers comprehend the relevance and role of digital marketing services in business growth and development. digital marketing company in delhi
https://www.crackz4u.info/
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing beautiful content on your blog. Get the latest trick of technology Pubg Free Items Download Your favourite urdu poetries Urdu poetry
ReplyDeleteIf you are interested in knowing how you can take care of your beloved vehicle properly then www.mysmallgarage.com should be your go-to place. It has tons of great tips and articles that helps car fanatics all over the globe.
ReplyDeletethis website make you rich.먹튀
ReplyDeleteThis article is very good, so I think the web will go a long way and a good blog will prove that you are doing a great job, thank you
ReplyDeletehttp://duanamaz.com/index.php/2020/06/02/benifits-of-lohe-qurani-in-hindi/
메이저사이트 메이저놀이터 먹튀검증your go-to place. It has tons of great tips and articles that helps car fanatics all over the globe.
ReplyDelete비스펙스 It's best to make money at home these days.
ReplyDeletebispexAnyone can make money.
ReplyDeletebispex
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing. I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopeful that you will write many more posts like this one.
ReplyDeleteHow to lose weight fast without exercise
Weight Loss Diet Plan
Fat Cutter Drink
Diet Plan for Weight Loss
Veg Diet Plan
Weight Gain Diet Plan
BEST DIET PLAN FOR WEIGHT LOSS
ReplyDeleteThank you for this wondrous post, Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site.
This is a curation of ongoing and completed COVID-19 Research responses by Kampala International University (KIU). KIU is the number one private university in Uganda and is currently ranked number 4 out of 65 universities in the country according to the January 2020 Webometrics Ranking of World Universities.
KIU COVID-19 Research
Happy New Year 2021
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteAwesome blog.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.
sai baba hd images
sai baba images
hanuman images
sai baba images
very useful information
ReplyDelete슬롯사이트
Thank you for sharing the valuable information
ReplyDelete토토사이트
valuable information
ReplyDelete토토사이트
파워볼사이트
ReplyDeleteI still wonder why people still use comments as a way of traffic
ReplyDeletecan someone guide? algeriahome
Thanks For Sharing great info with us
ReplyDelete[url=https://whatsappstatus2k.com/]best status[/url]
[url=https://whatsappstatus2k.com/best-friend-status]Best Friend Status 2020[/url]
[url=https://whatsappstatus2k.com/love-attitude-status/]Love Attitude Status 2020[/url]
[url=https://whatsappstatus2k.com/hurt-status-for-whatsapp/]Hurt Status for Whatsapp[/url]
[url=https://whatsappstatus2k.com/alone-status-for-whatsapp-2020/]Alone Status for Whatsapp[/url]
[url=https://bit.ly/31jsEmX]Status for Whatsapp[/url]
Story Time: The time when I made my own college teacher my sex buddy. Check the full story here.
ReplyDeletehey very post i loved it powerdirector mod apk
ReplyDeleteA congressional representative serves terms of two years, a senator six, a president four. Partisans all, they win or lose elections, they come, and they go. A police officer's career has no fixed term
ReplyDeletehttps://www.betting33.com
but that officer's effectiveness in the community depends exclusively on the legitimacy the people grant him or her. Demonstrate partisan bias, and that legitimacy will dissolve -- perhaps in an instant.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.syy577.com
Ask a competent police officer "Which side are you on?" and the answer you will hear is not the Republican side or the Democratic side but your side. Of course, police have political opinions, and, these days, they are often strong opinions. But everyone in law enforcement, from leadership down to street level, needs to discipline themselves to act on those opinions only at the polls and off-duty.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.dok222.com
My response to officers and their leadership is this: The people cannot read your mind or peer into your soul, but they can hear what you say and see -- as well as feel -- what you do. What is more, they share your words and your acts on social media.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.ccclub700.com
Let these be just, measured, and resolutely apolitical. For the police must serve just one side, the American community -- gloriously diverse as it is in race, religion, appearance, lifestyle, opinion, and political affiliation.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.cacash9.com
Achi Batein
ReplyDeletehttps://www.achibatein.xyz
achi batein
achi batain in urdu
achi baatein
achi bat
achi batain urdu
zindagi ki achi batain
achi batin
achay logon ki achi batain
achi achi baatein
achi baat in urdu
achi batein urdu
achi batain urdu
khubsurat batain
achi batain islam urdu
achi batein images
Dofollow backlinks
ReplyDeletePak24tv
awesome post and written in a very simple and impressive language. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeletehealth tips in urdu
https://zulqarnainbharwana.com/princess-eugenie/
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing.I found a lot of interesting information here
ReplyDeletejual burner riello R40
jual control burner simens
jual control burner honeywell
jual hot water boiler
jual pompa ksb lengkap
jual thermal oil murah
making steam boilers
thermal oil heater 400.000 kcal
https://zulqarnainbharwana.com/charlie-hebdo/
ReplyDeleteI am really happy to say it’s an interesting post to read . I learn new information from your article , you are doing a great job . Keep it up
ReplyDeleteDevops Training in USA
Hadoop Training in Hyderabad
Python Training in Hyderabad
I am too good that I found this website here.
ReplyDeletecrackkits
crackskit
ijicrack
Thanks for this article. It's so this inspiring.We All know that workout is best remaining healthy and fit .
ReplyDeleteSo Please also read my content.
Sarathi Parivahan Driving License
Wow What A Nice And Great Article,Thankyou SO much for Giving Us Such a Nice & Helpful articles ,I visit your Website reguraly.
So also read my artcial..
CSC RAP Exam ""
I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopeful that you will write many more posts like this one.
ReplyDelete25 Best Google Chrome Extensions in Hindi
nice blog.
ReplyDeletei like your post is very interesting and informative.
https://foodpur.org/
We have access to over 61 different banks. We are independent & have the clients best. interest. Making People’s Dreams become a REALITY! Book An Appointment. View News. View Team. Highlights: Appointment Available, Expert Available, Loan Calculators Available.
ReplyDeletehome loan broker melbourne
Apply All Sarkari Latest Jobs
ReplyDeleteApply All Sarkari Latest Jobs
ReplyDeleteI've been searching for 한국야동 hours on this topic 무료야동사이트, and finally I found your post 무료성인야동, and I've read your post 일본야동 and I'm very impressed 무료야동. We prefer your opinion 성인사진 and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion 성인야동. When would you like to visit my site? 조개모아
ReplyDeleteAwesome blog you have here 온라인카지노 but I was wondering if you knew of any forums 스포츠토토 that cover the same topics talked about here 먹튀검증사이트? I’d really like to be a part of group where I can get suggestions 안전놀이터 from other experienced people 추천픽 that share the same interest 먹튀사이트. If you have any recommendations 검증사이트, please let me know 먹중소. Bless you! 먹튀중개소
ReplyDeleteJust keep up the good work. One day you will succeed. I am so glad for you admin.
ReplyDeletemiracle box crack
crackprovst
refx nexus crack
enscape3d for sketchup crack
radioboss serial key
vysor pro crack
output arcade vst crack
I just like the helpful information you provide on your articles.
ReplyDeleteI’ll bookmark your blog and test again here frequently.
I am reasonably sure I will be told many new stuff proper right here!
Good luck for the next!
यूपी गन्ना पर्ची
Really I enjoy your site with effective and useful information. It is included very nice post with a lot of our resources.thanks for share. i enjoy this post 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteJust admiring your work and wondering how you managed this blog so well. It’s so remarkable that I can't afford to not go through this valuable information whenever I surf the internet! 사설토토
ReplyDeleteWonderful article. Thanks too much for the breakdown you have presented here. I am still sort-of an illiterate on this topic. So this post was really helpful to me personally. My husband just launched his own ebook on this issue and I think some things learned from your post would enable me personally to give him the necessary support. Thanks! 메이저토토
ReplyDeleteI want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!!! I definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog! 메이저놀이터
ReplyDeleteI appreciate you taking the time to talk about them with people. 토토
ReplyDeleteLovely article mate! 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteVery good written article. It will be supportive to anyone who utilizes it, including me. Keep doing what you are doing – can’r wait to read more posts. 사설스포츠토토
ReplyDeleteI really like your take on the issue. I now have a clear idea on what this matter is all about.. 토토
ReplyDeleteI am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work! 안전공원
ReplyDeleteI favor the idea, such a good deal 토토검증
ReplyDeletehi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back. 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteI am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work. 먹튀검증
ReplyDeleteGreat article and a nice way to promote online. I'm satisfied with the information that you provided 토토사이트
ReplyDeleteI feel a lot more people need to read this, very good info! 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteThere is definately a great deal to know about this subject. I like all of the points you've made 토토
ReplyDeleteI got too much interesting stuff on your blog. I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! Keep up the good work 바카라사이트
ReplyDeleteInteresting and amazing how your post is! It Is Useful and helpful for me That I like it very much, and I am looking forward to Hearing from your next.. 슈어맨
ReplyDeleteIts a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteThis is worth it to read for everyone. Thank you for sharing good ideas to all your readers and continue inspiring us 먹튀폴리스
ReplyDeleteSonarworks Reference 4 Crack is amazing sound reference software that removes unwanted sound coloration and delivers the same accurate studio reference sound on all speakers. This is designed to calibrate systems to achieve the smoothest possible amplitude-frequency response in the room.
ReplyDeleteSonarworks Reference 4 Studio Edition Crack
I found your this post while searching for information about blog-related research ... It's a good post .. keep posting and updating information. 먹튀폴리스
ReplyDeleteI feel very amazed that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from it. 이기자벳
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteGreat information. Thanks for sharing the article.
full stack development course in hyderabad
full stack development training in hyderabad
We review the top-rated best coffee makers.... Read more bestcoffeemakersonline...
ReplyDeleteWe understand that selling your home can be a difficult and confusing process, especially if you are in behind in your payments or have a home in need of repair. Our We Buy Houses investors can simplify the process by making you a clear, cash offer to purchase your home, along with presenting other options that may be available to you.
ReplyDeleteSell Your House Fast
I've been searching for 한국야동 hours on this topic 무료야동사이트, and finally I found your post 무료성인야동, and I've read your post 일본야동 and I'm very impressed 무료야동. We prefer your opinion 성인사진 and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion 성인야동. When would you like to visit my site? 조개모아
ReplyDeleteI've been searching for 토렌트사이트 hours on this topic 야동사이트, and finally I found your post 먹튀검증사이트, and I've read your post 웹툰사이트 and I'm very impressed 성인용품. We prefer your opinion 스포츠중계 and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion 드라마다시보기. When would you like to visit my site? 한인사이트 무료야동
ReplyDeleteI've been searching for 한국야동 hours on this topic 무료야동사이트, and finally I found your post 무료성인야동, and I've read your post 일본야동 and I'm very impressed 무료야동. We prefer your opinion 성인사진 and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion 성인야동. When would you like to visit my site? 조개모아
ReplyDeleteBest Window Tinting service in Elgin Illinois. if you happen to live in Illinois or at nearby area you can have you car or any window tint by the Cutting Edge Window Tinting.
ReplyDeleteCuttingedgewindowtinting at Elgin Illinois
https://www.wboc.com/story/43722582/cutting-edge-is-the-best-legal-window-tinting-service-you-can-have-in-elgin-illinois
Brookside is selling hand sanitizer that not only kill the germs and viruses but it can also be used as a mosturizer. CBD hand sanitizer can provide you with many benefits you can order it online by visiting.
ReplyDeleteBrooksideCBD Hand Sanitizer
www.ktvn.com/story/43957395/things-that-will-make-you-lovecbd-living-hand-sanitizer
It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I'd without a doubt donate to this fantastic blog! 스포츠토토
ReplyDeleteI will suggest mainly good as well as accountable ideas, consequently notice: 검증사이트
ReplyDeleteGreetings! Very helpful advice in this particular article! It’s the little changes which will make the largest changes. Thanks for sharing 사다리사이트
ReplyDeletethank you for your interesting infomation. 메이저놀이터
ReplyDeleteI know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. 스포츠중계
ReplyDeleteThanks for the blog filled with so many information. 카지노사이트
ReplyDeleteStopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. 안전놀이터
ReplyDeleteWe all need to see this kind of information, and we really hope that this article will spread widely.메이저사이트추천 May the good things always be full.
ReplyDeleteThat's a wonderful piece of writing. Not as good as you, but I'm wearing it like this. Take a look.사설토토사이트
ReplyDeletefear street part 1 1994 torrent download
ReplyDeletefear street part 1 1994 torrent download
Nice articel, This article help me very well. Thank you. Also please check my article on my site about htaccess tutorial.
ReplyDeleteNice articel, This article help me very well. Thank you. Also please check my article on my site about Best wordpress Tutorial.
ReplyDeleteDVDFab Crack is a DVD and Blue-ray copying and conversion tool. The software has different versions that support Windows and Mac OS. It can professionally burn or copy DVDs, and Blue-ray did sit a variety of features that allows you to copy, clone, rip, burn, and decrypt DVDs. DVDFab allows you to convert other formats of videos to DVD or blue-ray and DVD and blue-ray to other formats.
ReplyDeletedvdfab-crack
People with schizophrenia attempt suicide more frequently than the general population, and about 10% of those who attempt suicide die. Predicting suicide in a person with schizophrenia is very difficult, so if a patient talks about suicide or attempts to commit suicide, he or she should seek professional help immediately.
ReplyDelete메이저사이트
“Useful Post”
ReplyDeleteRoblox Transparent PNG Logos That you can download to your computer and use in your designs.
Artisteer Crack License Key is a web design automation product that instantly creates great and unique website templates and blog themes. you can design WordPress and Blogger blogs and professional websites and export them as Google Blogger templates, WordPress themes.
ReplyDeleteMixpad Crack
Clonedvd Ultimate Crack
Microsoft Project Crack
nazar-ki-dua
ReplyDeleteBuri-Nazar-Ki-Dua buri-nazar-se-bachne-ki-dua nazar-se-bachne-ki-dua ki puri information hindi me
Websofy Software Private Limited, you can easily get reasonable services to develop a beautiful website. Web Development Company in Lucknow |
ReplyDeleteDigital Marketing Company in Lucknow
SEO Expert in Lucknow
https://textspeed.in/
ReplyDeletepromotional sms chennai
Kosa Silk Sarees at Bunkar Sarees are the pure refined version of modern-day Tussar silk. These sarees are mainly woven in the Vidarbha part of Maharashtra. Normally, the Tussar Silk Sarees are considered as the foremost popular sarees in India. We at Bunkar Sarees Online bring you the fantastic designs of the Kosa Silk Sarees at the lowest price range. Whether you are looking for the finest and pure silk sarees, then here is your best option for easily enjoying your shopping.
ReplyDeletePure Silk Sarees in Lucknow
Bridal Sarees in Lucknow
Know About aud to usd Login - The Complete Guide To Login Pepperstone Account
ReplyDeletehttps://www.smarttechjr.com/
ReplyDeletebest online coding classes for kids Chennai
Whnefits Of Using Amitrade
ReplyDeleteCoding for kids in Malaysia
ReplyDeletehttps://smarttechjrs.blogspot.com/2021/10/top-5-programming-languages-for-kids-to.html
Able2extract Professional Crack is a powerful and intelligent software to convert PDF files to HTML, TXT, PowerPoint, Excel, Publisher, OpenOffice, and AutoCAD files.
ReplyDeleteAdobe Audition CC Crack
Mixpad Crack
Rrazer Surround Pro Crack
Pycharm Crack
Wondershare DVD Creator Crack
Thanks for sharing the information, for more information check coding for kids chennai
ReplyDeleteand visit smarttechjr.com
Thank you for sharing this. It was helpful. Keep sharing such things. Wonderful information keep it up for us.
ReplyDeletebest sms service provider in india chennai
bulk sms service chennai tamil nadu
best bulk sms service provider in chennai
bulk whatsapp provider chennai
نازلترین قیمت پنکک را در وب سایت سین دخت مشاهده کنید
ReplyDeleteIt’s really a cool and useful piece of info. I am satisfied that you simply shared this useful information with us.Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteartificial jewellery in chennai
jewellery online in chennai
imitation jewellery in chennai
women jewellery in chennai
Sign In To Your Oanda Account And Manage Your Asset Portfolio. Use The Platform To Trade Currencies Or Cryptocurrency Online. For More Information, Read About Their Security Features And How To Set Up Auto Trading.
ReplyDeleteThis is very helpful information and hope you provide us more information
ReplyDeleteThankyou!
jewellery in chennai
fashion jewellery in chennai
artificial jewellery in chennai
jewellery online in chennai
imitation jewellery in chennai
women jewellery in chennai
jewellery stores in chennai
jewellery shop in chennai
choker necklace in chennai
jewellery set in chennai
online jewellery shopping in chennai
online jewellery store in chennai
design jewellery in chennai
This blog is fantastic, and I enjoy reading your articles. Continue to do a fantastic job! Many people are looking for this information, and you may tremendously help them.
ReplyDeleteSEO Company in Chennai
I've learned a few useful things here. It's definitely worth bookmarking for future reference. I'm curious as to how much effort you put into creating such an excellent educational website.
ReplyDeletesoftware development company in Chennai
Thanks for such a fantastic blog. Where else could anyone get that kind of info written in such a perfect way? I have a presentation that I am presently writhing on, and I have been on the look out for such great information. 꽁머니
ReplyDeleteYou make it seem so plain in your presentation, but I believe this is a subject that I will never grasp. It appears to me to be extremely complex and broad. I eagerly await your next post and will do my best to comprehend it!
ReplyDeleteios app development company in chennai
Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to
ReplyDeletethis website before but after browsing through some of the
post I realized it’s new to me. Nonetheless, I’m definitely glad
I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back
often!
Best UI/UX Design Companies in Chennai
Mobile app development company in chennai
App development company in chennai
mobile app development in chennai
app development company in chennai
Thank you very much for sharing!! The mastery of martial arts fascinates me. Bruce Lee is one of my favourite actors; his innate ability in martial arts is incredible.
ReplyDeleteSAAS Application Development in chennai
Ecommerce development company in chennai
Online Shopping Website Development company in chennai
CRM Development Companies in Chennai
Great Blog! you did a Fantastic website! Keep up the incredible job, you did a really good job on this post. good job in this post keep up the good work
ReplyDeletephotoshoot in andaman
photographers in andaman
photoshoot at andaman
andaman photoshoot
pre wedding shoot in andaman
photoshoot in havelock andaman
I'm not sure where you got your facts, but it's an intriguing topic. I need to set aside some time to gather and digest more information. I needed this information for my goal, and you gave it to me.
ReplyDeletebest sms provider in india chennai
best bulk sms service provider in chennai
sms service provider in chennai
sms marketing chennai
best sms provider in india chennai
really very good blog.its very useful for me
ReplyDeletehttps://textspeed.in/sim-based-bulk-sms.html
Tenorshare iAnyGo Crack allows you to restore iPad/iPod touch and iPhone from its backup file
ReplyDeleteiAnyGo Crack Mac
Wow. This is amazing site for me. Good work on this webpage. Here is a detailed article on Earn money from youtube. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteHello, everything is fine here, and everyone is eager to offer their knowledge, which is wonderful. Continue writing!
ReplyDeleteCoding for kids in Singapore
Your article appeals to me. This is a blog that everyone should read. Because this site is so important to everyone, I'm going to share this article. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge with us.
ReplyDeleteThank you for providing such a useful and attractive blog, with really useful information and things I never imagined, and I would recommend that you write more blogs and blog posts like that for us. Once again, thank you.
ReplyDeleteYou're so fascinating! I don't believe I've ever read anything like that before. It's really refreshing to come across someone who has some unique perspectives on this subject. Thank you for getting things started. This weblog is exactly what the internet needs: someone with a little bit of creativity!
ReplyDeletephotographers in andaman
photoshoot in havelock andaman
photoshoot in andaman
pre wedding shoot in Andaman
andaman photoshoot
photoshoot at andaman
This is a fantastic article with a lot of useful information. These types of articles keep visitors interested in the website, so keep sharing more...
ReplyDeleteRank In Forex .. We are a Digital Marketing agency focusing on Digital Marketing For Forex Broker. We have been on top of Google search for the phrases you can see on the right and we will be happy to tell you how we did it.
ReplyDeleteNo One Knows How Many Links Are Required To Rank On The First Page Of Google, But It's Safe To Say That There Are A Lot. We Will Do All The Work For You, Including The Tedious Free Seo Audit For Forex Brokers Process, For A Reasonable Price. We'll Make Sure That You Have A Complete List Of Links, Both Old And New, To Keep Your Site's Rankings High.
ReplyDeleteAt Market Forex Net Our Aim Is To Provide You With The Information Necessary To Make An Educated Choice When Finding The Right Trading Service Provider. We List A Variety Of Brokers Offering Many Different Platforms And Services. Gaining Access To A Wide Range Of The Best Online Brokers Will Allow You To Compare Them Side By Side And Make The Right Decision For Your Trading Needs.
ReplyDelete