Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Safe top-level mutable variables for Haskell

I uploaded the safe-globals package for Haskell, which lets you declare top-level mutable variables like so:

{-# LANGUAGE TemplateHaskell #-}
import Data.Global
import Data.IORef

declareIORef "ref"
[t| Int |]
[e| 3 |]

main = do
readIORef ref >>= print -- prints 3
writeIORef ref 5
readIORef ref >>= print -- prints 5

This creates a module-level binding

ref :: IORef Int

which can be managed through the usual module import/export mechanism.

Why global state?

Global state is a sign of bad software design, especially in Haskell. Why would we ever need it? Suppose you're wrapping a C library which is not thread-safe. Using a (hidden!) global lock, you can expose an interface which is simple and safe. In other words, you're using global state to compensate for others using global state.1 Another use case is generating unique identifiers to speed up comparison of values. This can be done without breaking referential transparency, but you need a source of IDs which is really and truly global.

In these situations it's typical to create global variables using a hack such as

ref :: IORef Int
ref = unsafePerformIO (newIORef 3)
{-# NOINLINE ref #-}

My library is just a set of Template Haskell macros for the same hack. If global variables are seldom needed, then what good are these macros?

  • Writing out the hack each time is unsafe. I might forget the NOINLINE pragma, or subvert the type system with a polymorphic reference. The safe-globals library prevents these mistakes. I'm of the opinion — and I know it's not shared by all — that even questionable techniques should be made as safe as possible. Call it "harm reduction" if you like.

  • In ten years, if GHC 9 requires an extra pragma for safety, then safe-globals can be updated, without changing every package that uses it. If JHC's ACIO feature is ported to GHC, then safe-globals can take advantage and get rid of the hacks entirely.

But the direct impetus to write safe-globals was the appearance of the global-variables library, which drew some attention in the Haskell community. global-variables aims to solve the same problem, using a different approach with a number of drawbacks. The rest of this article outlines some of these drawbacks.

Spooky action at a distance

Among the stated features of global-variables are

Avoid having to pass references explicitly throughout the program in order to let distant parts communicate. Enable a communication by convention scheme, where e.g. different libraries may communicate without code dependencies.

This refers to the fact that two global refs with the same name string will become entangled, no matter where in a program they were declared. This is certainly a bug, not a feature. Untracked interactions between different components are the archetypal defect in software engineering.

Neither is there a clear way for a user of global-variables to opt out of this misfeature. The best you can do is augment your names with some prefix which you hope is unique — the same non-solution used by C libraries. Haskell solves namespace problems with a module system and a package system. global-variables circumvents both.

Still, suppose that you choose "communication by convention" for your library. You'll need to manually document the name and type of every ref used by this communication, since they aren't tracked by the type system. A mismatch (as from a library upgrade) will cause silent breakage. Worse, you need to tell every library user how to initialize your library's own variables, and hope that they do it correctly. When a ref is given different initializers in different declarations, the result is indeterminate.

Type clashes

A polymorphic reference, with a type like ∀ t. IORef t, breaks the type system. You can write a value of one type and then read it with another type. So it's important for global-variables to disallow polymorphic refs. The mechanism it uses is that each declaration is implicitly a family of refs, one for each monomorphic type (via Typeable).

Now consider this reasonable-looking program:

{-# LANGUAGE NoMonomorphismRestriction #-}
import Data.Global -- from global-variables
import Data.IORef

-- Define the famous factorial function
fact :: Integer -> Integer
fact 0 = 1
fact n = n * fact (n-1)

-- Now use it through a global ref
ref = declareIORef "ref" 0
main = do
writeIORef ref (length "hello")
r <- readIORef ref
print (fact r)

This will print 1, not 120. The ref is written at type Int (the return type of length) and an implicitly different ref is read at type Integer (because of the subsequent call to fact).

You can certainly argue that top-level refs should always be declared with a monomorphic type signature. Indeed, my library enforces this. But global-variables doesn't, and can't. Making type clashes a run-time error would be a step in the right direction.

  1. A common response is that locking should be added in C code; however, concurrent programming in C is cumbersome and dangerous. It's much easier, if a bit ugly, to implement locking on the Haskell side. You could however store an MVar lock in a C global variable via StablePtr. Has anyone done this?


  1. Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference
    jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
    jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung

  2. http://www.ar-kan7.com/%D9%85%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%82%D9%87-%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AD-%D8%A8%D8%AD%D9%81%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%B7%D9%86/

  3. Packers and Movers Bangalore - Reliable and Verified Household Shifting Service Providers Give Reasonable ###Packers and Movers Charges. Cheap and Best Office Relocation Compare Quotation for Assurance for Local and Domestic House Shifting and Get estimates today to save upto 20%, ***Read Customer Reviews - @ Packers And Movers Bangalore

  4. https://cracksoon.com/dvdfab-crack-version-keygen-lifetime/
    Cracked Here is a useful place where you can easily find Activators, Patch, Full version software Free Download, License key, serial key, keygen, Activation Key and Torrents.
    Get all of these by easily just on a single click.

  5. https://usecracked.com/hma-pro-vpn-latest-crack-license-key/
    Cracked Here is a useful place where you can easily find Activators, Patch, Full version software Free Download, License key, serial key, keygen, Activation Key and Torrents.

  6. https://crackpluskey.com/adobe-photoshop-cc-crack-is-here/
    Adobe Photoshop CC Crack you can use mixing. It also gives you the function to adjust the color level and add texture. You can also improve the filter quality. Letters and alpha are used to improve quality. Graphic icons used for web and layout design. Overall, Marvel and Steve used to be comic. But the addition of photoshop is a dream and a design. The added options complete the recording process. Photoshop editor software comes with the best engineering tools imaginable.

  7. https://crackedversion.com/r-studio-crack/
    R-Studio License key can help you to select to do the partition where you want to do and analyze it from the press and the scan button from your toolbar. While the utility feature lets you scan each partition and also allows you to see the files and folder you recover. The user has an option to decide which of these can want to be active in it. And you can also expand it while adding it to the new files.

  8. Packers and Movers Bangalore as a Services providing company can make all the difference to your ###Home Relocation experience. Bangalore based Company which offers versatile solutions, Right team that easily reduce the stress associated with a ✔✔✔Household Shifting, ***Vehicle Transportation. we help things run smoothly and reduce breakages and offer you seamless, Affordable, Reliable Shifting Services, Compare Shifting Charges. @ Packers And Movers Bangalore

  9. I really like your content. Your post is really informative. I have learned a lot from your article and I’m looking forward to applying it in my article given below!.
    TubeDigger Crack Free Download
    Enscape3D Crack Download
    Unity Pro Crack Download
    Idm Crack Download

  10. تقوم الشركه بنقل الأثاث داخل شاحنات مغلقه لضمان اقصى حماية للأثاث اثناء عملية النقل , فالشركه لديها اسطول كبير من السيارات التى تضمن السرعه والجوده فى نقل الأثاث من والى جمع انحاء المملكه, والشركه ايضاً لديها طاقم من افضل الفنيين والعمال المتخصصين فى نقل الأثاث وتغليفه لحمايته الصدمات والتلف فالشركه هدفها الأول والأخير هو رضاء عملائها
    نقل الأثاث الثقيل ليس بالأمر السهل على الإطلاق ، وحتى أقل من ذلك عندما يتعين عليك تحريكه لأعلى الدرج! سواء كنت تنتقل إلى منزل جديد في طابق أعلى في شقة لا تحتوي على مصعد أو تحتاج إلى نقل بعض الأثاث إلى طابق آخر في المنزل ، فمن المهم استخدام الأسلوب الصحيح للقيام بذلك بأمان. اتخذ بعض الإجراءات لحماية الأثاث ومنزلك ونفسك من التلف والإصابة قبل أن تبدأ في نقل أي شيء. احمل قطعًا كبيرة على الدرج باستخدام مساعد أو استخدم عربة لنقل القطع الثقيلة الصغيرة والمتوسطة الحجم بمفردك بينما يكتشفك شخص ما من الأسفل. استفد من المعدات والتقنيات المتخصصة لتسهيل رفع بعض العناصر ووضعها في مكانها.
    تقديم خدمة نقل الأثاث بأفضل خدمة وأقل تكلفة وأسرع وقت وملائم للعملاء لتنفيذ عملية نقل الأثاث وتوفير المال والوقت للعملاء. جميع خدمات شركتنا بمعنى الخدمات الشاملة.

    شركة نقل عفش

  11. ปัจจุบันสัตว์เลี้ยงยอดนิยมอย่างสุนัข ก็กำลังมาแรงและได้รับความสนใจอย่างมาก เพราะเป็นสัตว์ที่น่ารัก เเสนรู้ เป็นเพื่อคลายเหงาเป็นอย่างดี วันนี้ทาง evanasa มีสุนัขสุดน่ารัก เเละเหมาะสำหรับผู้เล่นที่กำลังมองหาน้องหมาสุกตัวมาดูเเล เป็นสายพันธู์ที่มีความนน่ารัก เเละไม่ควรพลาดสำหรับคนที่รักสัตว์อย่างเเน่นอน.